*
Album Review: U2's Carnaval de Luz — I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For… and Apparently Neither Has U2 - Wyatt Poindexter - The Agency Oklahoma

Album Review: U2's Carnaval de Luz — I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For… and Apparently Neither Has U2 - Wyatt Poindexter - The Agency Oklahoma

Album Review: U2's Carnaval de Luz — I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For… and Apparently Neither Has U2

A brutally honest and slightly painful review from a lifelong U2 fan who desperately wanted to love this album.

By Wyatt Poindexter

Before I get started, let me explain something. I've never written an album review before, and yes, I realize this is my real estate blog. Normally, I'm writing about luxury homes, extraordinary properties, and the Oklahoma real estate market. But anyone who knows me knows that music has always been one of my greatest passions, and U2 has been a huge part of my life for more than 40 years.

So today, we're taking a little break from real estate to talk about something I absolutely love. And unfortunately, this particular review isn't going to be pretty.

Let me begin with a confession. I absolutely love U2.

I've been a devoted fan for over 40 years. I've seen them live 27 times, traveled around the world to attend their concerts, and even made the pilgrimage to Ireland to see them perform at Croke Park in Dublin. I've collected their music, followed their careers, defended their questionable decisions, and spent more money on U2 tickets than I care to admit.

I've stood in stadiums with tens of thousands of fans singing "Where the Streets Have No Name" at the top of my lungs. I've experienced the magic of "Bad," the emotion of "One," and the incredible energy of "The Fly" and "Even Better Than the Real Thing."

In other words, I'm not some casual listener who discovered U2 when Apple mysteriously deposited an album onto everyone's iPhone.

I'm a U2 lifer.

Which makes what I'm about to say particularly painful.

Their new album, Carnaval de Luz, should have been called Carnaval de LOSE.

And unfortunately, that's being generous.

I Had Such High Hopes. Then I Pressed Play.

When I first heard "Greatest Show on Earth," I was genuinely excited.

Finally! There was a spark of the U2 I remembered. It gave me hope that after years of waiting, the band was preparing to deliver something special.

I thought maybe this was the beginning of another great chapter.

Instead, it turned out to be the greatest false advertising campaign on Earth.

I went into this album wanting to love it. I practically begged it to be good.

Unfortunately, by the time I made it through several tracks, I was looking for the nearest emergency exit.

I still haven't found what I'm looking for. And apparently, it isn't on this album.

Has Anyone Seen The Edge? Specifically, His Guitar?

One of the greatest things about U2 has always been The Edge.

His guitar playing is instantly recognizable. Nobody sounds like him. The delay, the atmosphere, the soaring melodies, those unforgettable riffs that can fill an entire stadium with just a handful of notes.

Think about "Pride (In the Name of Love)," "Where the Streets Have No Name," "Bad," "The Fly," "Bullet the Blue Sky," or "Even Better Than the Real Thing."

That guitar sound helped define an entire generation of rock music.

So where is it?

Seriously. Has anyone checked whether The Edge accidentally left his guitar at the Sphere in Las Vegas?

Because on this album, I barely recognize the band.

Everything sounds so overproduced, so polished, and so buried beneath layers of studio effects that the personality of U2 seems to have disappeared.

I don't want another atmospheric keyboard experiment. I want The Edge playing guitar like The Edge!

I've never been a huge fan of U2's keyboard-heavy songs, with "New Year's Day" being the glorious exception.

At this point, I'd be thrilled to hear The Edge accidentally drop his guitar down a flight of stairs. At least we'd hear some strings.

Remember When U2 Actually Wrote Epic Songs?

This is the band that gave us "One," "Pride (In the Name of Love)," "Where the Streets Have No Name," "Bad," "With or Without You," "Sunday Bloody Sunday," "Even Better Than the Real Thing," "Until the End of the World," and "The Fly."

These weren't just songs. They were experiences.

They had emotion, passion, unforgettable melodies, incredible guitar work, and the ability to make 80,000 people feel like they were part of something extraordinary.

Where are those songs now?

I couldn't find one track on this new album that comes remotely close to that level of greatness.

In fact, I'll go one step further.

The B-sides from Achtung Baby are 100 times better than this entire album.

And I'm not exaggerating much.

Give me "Lady With the Spinning Head," "Salomé," or "Satellite of Love" over this new material any day of the week.

Achtung Baby was U2 reinventing themselves brilliantly.

Carnaval de Luz sounds like U2 reinventing themselves into a band I wouldn't recognize if they were playing in a hotel lobby.

The Dolly Parton Song? Oh, Sweet Mercy.

I was genuinely excited about the Dolly Parton collaboration, especially because I had understood it might be her final song.

Dolly is an absolute legend, and the thought of two musical institutions coming together sounded promising.

Unfortunately, the result left me completely disappointed.

I love Dolly. I love U2.

Apparently, loving two things individually doesn't guarantee you'll love them together.

I love steak. I love ice cream. That doesn't mean I want someone putting a ribeye in my milkshake.

And that's about how this collaboration landed with me.

Bono, Didn't You Once Warn Us About This?

I remember Bono making a comment years ago along the lines that a band only gets so many bad albums before it's finished.

I believe the number was three.

Well, Bono, I hate to bring up your own philosophy, but we may need to schedule a meeting.

For me, U2's last truly great studio album was 2004's How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb.

That was over two decades ago.

Think about that.

A band that once seemed incapable of making a bad record has now spent years releasing music that, in my opinion, doesn't come close to its legendary catalog.

I'm not asking them to remake The Joshua Tree or Achtung Baby.

I'm asking them to remember what made those albums extraordinary.

Great songwriting. Passion. Musical chemistry. Larry's drums. Adam's bass. The Edge's guitar. Bono's voice.

Four musicians creating something magical together.

Not a hundred layers of production trying to manufacture something meaningful.

Sometimes you need to stop trying to find what you're looking for and remember what you already had.

And Because I'm Apparently a Glutton for Punishment… I Bought FIVE Vinyl Copies!

Here's where this story gets even more embarrassing.

Before hearing the entire album, I actually ordered FIVE different vinyl editions of Carnaval de Luz.

Yes, FIVE!

Different versions, different colors, all because I'm a lifelong U2 fan and collector who was convinced this was going to be something special.

Now? I'm fairly certain none of them will ever be opened.

And not because I'm protecting their future collectible value.

I'm genuinely afraid that if I break the shrink-wrap, the music might escape!

I've officially gone from collecting U2 records to collecting reminders of questionable financial decisions.

As someone who works in real estate, I should know better than to invest in something without doing my due diligence.

Apparently, my love for U2 completely overruled my professional judgment.

Maybe I can list the records as five beautifully packaged properties with tremendous potential, but absolutely no interest once you get inside.

At least the album covers will look nice in my collection.

I guess you could say I'm officially Stuck in a Moment You Can't Get Out Of.

And unfortunately, I bought five copies of that moment.

I Couldn't Even Finish Some of the Songs.

This may be the most painful admission of all.

After waiting years for new U2 music, I found myself skipping tracks before they were even finished.

Me!

The guy who has seen them 27 times.

The guy who traveled to Ireland to watch them perform.

The guy who has probably listened to "Bad" more times than Bono himself.

I couldn't get through some of these songs.

And that says everything.

After I'd heard enough, I did what any emotionally traumatized U2 fan would do.

I immediately put The Joshua Tree and Achtung Baby on shuffle.

It was musical therapy.

Within minutes, "Where the Streets Have No Name" reminded me why I fell in love with this band in the first place.

"One" reminded me what incredible songwriting sounds like.

And "The Fly" reminded me that The Edge actually owns an electric guitar.

It was like returning home after a terrible vacation.

Is This the End of U2? Absolutely Not. At Least Not for Me.

Here's the funny thing.

Despite everything I've just written, I still love U2.

I always will.

They've provided the soundtrack to a huge part of my life. Their music has accompanied me through incredible experiences, unforgettable concerts, friendships, travels, and memories spanning four decades.

Nothing can take that away.

And when they announce their next tour, will I buy tickets?

Absolutely.

Will I travel to see them?

Probably.

Will I stand there singing every word of "Where the Streets Have No Name" like I'm 20 years old again?

Without question.

But will I be hoping they don't play too many songs from Carnaval de Luz?

With or without you, Bono, the answer is YES.

Final Verdict: A Beautiful Day? Not Even Close.

I wanted this album to be extraordinary. Instead, I found myself wondering if the band that gave us some of the greatest rock songs ever recorded had completely forgotten how to make a great rock album.

"Where the Streets Have No Name"? Apparently, that's where U2 went to record this album, because I certainly can't find them.

"With or Without You"? After listening to this album, I'm leaning heavily toward WITHOUT YOU.

"I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For"? Neither have I, Bono. And believe me, I searched every track.

"Beautiful Day"? Not the day I listened to this album.

"Sunday Bloody Sunday"? More like Sunday Bloody Disaster.

"Even Better Than the Real Thing"? At this point, I'd settle for something that even remotely resembles the real U2.

"One"? That's approximately how many songs I enjoyed.

"Bad"? Finally, a U2 song title that perfectly describes this entire album.

And "Until the End of the World"? That's about how long it felt like some of these songs lasted.

Maybe I should have listened to "Walk On" and just kept walking past this album.

My rating: -1 out of 10. Yes, NEGATIVE ONE!

I've waited years for this album, and now I feel like U2 owes me that time back. I didn't even know negative album ratings were possible until now.

Maybe some fans will appreciate this new musical direction. Maybe critics will find artistic brilliance that completely escaped me.

That's fine. Music is subjective.

But here's the crazy part. I'll still be first in line when they announce their next tour. I'll still travel to see them, buy the merchandise, and sing every word of their classics.

Because despite this musical disaster, U2 will always be one of my favorite bands.

Bono, Adam, Larry, and Edge, I still love you guys. But please, somebody find The Edge's guitar, unplug the keyboards, and remember what made U2 one of the greatest rock bands in history.

Until then, I'll be listening to The Joshua Tree, Achtung Baby, and The Unforgettable Fire.

One love. One life. One album I'd rather forget.

And Bono, if you're reading this, please don't take it personally.

I'm just a fan who still hasn't found what he's looking for.

Apparently, neither have you.

Wyatt Poindexter

U2 fan for over 40 years. 27 concerts. Multiple countries. Five unopened vinyl records. Still waiting for another masterpiece.

Work With Wyatt

Wyatt prides himself on his personal service and attention to his clients every detail, which has led him to a large base of referral and repeating clients. Contact Wyatt today!

Follow Me On Instagram