From a $37,500 Shack to a Dream Home: My Humble (and Slightly Drafty) Start in Real Estate

Let’s rewind to 1995.

I was a 20-something with ambition, a Toyota 4Runner, and not much else—including central heat and air. That year, I bought my very first house for a whopping $37,500. You heard that right. In today’s dollars, that’s… well, still barely enough to get a decent used car these days.

It was about 900 square feet of freshly remodeled humble pie, and I loved it.

Now, I say “remodeled,” but let’s not get carried away. The house had character. It came with one window unit that tried its best to cool the entire place—God bless it. I couldn’t afford central heat and air right away, so I did what every financially cautious homeowner does: I sweated and shivered for 12 months while saving up for HVAC like it was a luxury car.

The Garage Door Laundry Olympics

Here’s where things get real.

The washer and dryer were located in the garage, which—wait for it—had no door to the inside of the house. None. Nada. So to do laundry, I had to hop in my 4Runner, hit the garage remote from the driveway, lift the door like I was entering a secret bunker, and go do laundry like a suburban ninja.

When Angie moved in after we got married in 2000, she inherited this glamorous setup. My mom took one look at the “laundry plan” and basically said, “Oh no. Absolutely not.” She paid to add an interior door to the garage because, let’s be honest, sending your new daughter-in-law out to the driveway in her pajamas to start a spin cycle was not going to fly.

Meet My Sugar Momma (aka Angie)

Angie, bless her, moved into that little house with me when we got married. She was a second-grade teacher at Tulakes Elementary, making about $25,000 a year. I made even less than that—so technically, she was the breadwinner. Or as I like to call her: my sugar momma.
Let’s be clear: she definitely didn’t marry me for my money. Maybe it was my Toyota 4Runner. Maybe it was the window unit AC. Or maybe it was my killer 90210 sideburns that she loved. Who’s to say?

Our little house was so drafty that Angie had to wear thick socks or UGG-like boots with a small space heater by her feet just to stay warm at the desk during winter. Yes, we did wake up to a few blue and red flashing lights late at night with a handcuffed man lying face-first in our front yard.

We didn’t have much, but we had each other—and somehow, that made our 900-square-foot shack feel like a castle.

Trading Up: The Power of Real Estate (and Retro Décor)

A few years after our first home, we had the opportunity to buy a house in Bethany for $111,000. But this wasn’t just any house—it was built by my grandparents in 1967, and I had amazing childhood memories there. To me, it felt like a mansion. At 2,700 square feet, it may as well have been the White House compared to our 900-square-foot starter home.

Of course, it also came with orange shag carpet, owl paintings on nearly every wall, and chipped linoleum countertops that had seen better decades. And yes… the bathrooms had carpet. I don’t know who thought that was a good idea, but it was the ‘60s—let’s just say it was a different time.

Even with all its funky flair, that house had soul. The shower head in the primary bathroom? It hit me about chest level. Every morning was like trying to rinse off in a sink. Humbling, to say the least. I sold our first home for around $68,000, used the equity as a down payment, and we made the Bethany house our home for nearly 20 years.

Today, that same house is fully paid off and generates about $3,000 a month in rental income. Just another reason why I’m such a believer in real estate as a long-term investment—even if it starts with shag carpet and owl art.

The Real Secret to My Success: Her Name Is Angie

Through every home, every deal, every high and low—there’s one constant in my story: Angie.
She’s the one who believed in me when I wasn’t sure I believed in myself. I tried quitting Real Estate and she would change my mind. She prayed for us, supported us, laughed with me, and let’s be honest—put up with a LOT. I’ll never forget watching her leave early each morning for work, determined, graceful, and optimistic—even when times were tight.

The right partner can make you or break you. And Angie? She made me.

She’s the greatest blessing in my life, and without her, none of this would’ve happened. If it weren’t for Angie, I probably wouldn't have many friends. I’ve always kind of been a recluse or loner—but everyone loves Angie! Anyone that knows her always says, "She is an angel! She is the sweetest person I know." And honestly, that’s the truth.

My Final Thoughts: Humble Beginnings, Big Blessings

It’s easy to look at people’s highlight reels and assume they had it easy. But the truth? Every dream starts somewhere. Sometimes it’s in a tiny house with no garage door and a window unit that wheezes like a dying vacuum. Sometimes it’s with a second-grade teacher who believes in you more than you believe in yourself.

Don’t despise humble beginnings—they’re the training ground for your biggest victories. "Start small. Work hard. Pray through it all. Marry someone who makes you better. Stay humble. Tithe. Then watch what God can do with your faithfulness."

If I’ve learned anything from my journey, it’s this:

Success isn’t about where you start. It’s about who you become along the way.

And a little garage door access doesn’t hurt either.

Wyatt Poindexter
Managing Partner – The Agency Oklahoma
405-417-5466 | www.OKLuxuryHomes.com

#HumbleBeginnings #RealEstateJourney #WyattPoindexter #TheAgencyRE #ThankYouAngie #FirstTimeBuyer #RealEstateInvesting